Download PDF The Bill of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), by Learned Hand
This book The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand deals you better of life that can develop the top quality of the life more vibrant. This The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand is just what individuals now need. You are below and also you might be precise and also certain to obtain this publication The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand Never ever question to get it even this is merely a publication. You can get this publication The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand as one of your collections. But, not the collection to present in your shelfs. This is a priceless publication to be reviewing compilation.
The Bill of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), by Learned Hand
Download PDF The Bill of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), by Learned Hand
Book The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand is among the precious worth that will make you constantly abundant. It will certainly not mean as abundant as the money give you. When some people have lack to deal with the life, people with numerous publications sometimes will certainly be wiser in doing the life. Why must be publication The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand It is really not implied that publication The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand will give you power to reach everything. Guide is to review and also exactly what we suggested is the publication that is reviewed. You can likewise see how the book entitles The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand and also varieties of book collections are supplying below.
This book The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand is expected to be among the most effective vendor book that will make you really feel satisfied to get and read it for completed. As understood can usual, every book will certainly have certain things that will certainly make someone interested so much. Also it originates from the writer, kind, content, as well as the author. However, many people also take guide The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand based on the theme and also title that make them amazed in. and also below, this The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand is very recommended for you because it has intriguing title and also theme to read.
Are you actually a follower of this The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand If that's so, why do not you take this book now? Be the initial person that such as as well as lead this book The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand, so you can obtain the reason and also messages from this book. Never mind to be confused where to get it. As the various other, we discuss the connect to visit and also download and install the soft file ebook The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand So, you might not carry the published publication The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand all over.
The existence of the online publication or soft file of the The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand will certainly reduce individuals to obtain guide. It will additionally save even more time to just search the title or author or author to obtain until your book The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand is revealed. Then, you could go to the link download to check out that is provided by this site. So, this will be a very good time to begin appreciating this book The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand to review. Constantly good time with book The Bill Of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), By Learned Hand, consistently great time with cash to invest!
- Sales Rank: #3406903 in Books
- Published on: 1958
- Binding: Hardcover
- 82 pages
Most helpful customer reviews
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful.
How Prescient He Was: Learned Hand, The Paradigmatic Philosopher-Judge
By B. P. Hayek
Billings Learned Hand was born in 1872 destined to follow his father and grandfather not just into the law, but to the bench. He majored in Philosophy at Harvard, graduating summa cum laude, he earned the M.A. in Philosophy at Harvard, graduated with honors from Harvard Law School, and then entered the private practice of law. Hand is said to have remarked that he “was not very successful as a young lawyer” and “never was too happy at the bar,” finding much of it “dull,” “petty,” and unduly “formal.” Fortunately, he was rescued from the drudgery of law practice when appointed as a Federal District Court Judge by William Howard Taft – at the ripe old age of 37 – where he served for 15 years until being elevated to the Second Circuit by Calvin Coolidge. He took senior status in 1951, and in 1958 gave the Harvard Law School’s Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures. He is widely considered to be the greatest jurist never to be appointed to the Supreme Court, and has been quoted more often by legal scholars and the High Court itself more than any other judge never to be so elevated. Learned Hand died in 1961.
It has been said that Hand’s study of philosophy left a permanent residue on his thought generally and his jurisprudence in particular. I find this claim true beyond all reasonable doubt, for the study of philosophy, insofar as one genuinely pursues it, induces an enormous respect for both intellectual humility and an ironic brand of skepticism. It is no coincidence that Hand is claimed to have once described himself as “a conservative among liberals, and a liberal among conservatives” when it came to politics; for him, a devotion to the truth and the rule of law were paramount, meaning that he sacrificed neither to curry favor from any faction or for any gain of public popularity. Hand was, in other words, the paradigmatic philosopher-judge.
Hand’s 1958 Holmes Lectures are three in number. In Lecture I. “When a Court Should Intervene,” Hand presents his view of the implied authority for, and wisdom of, judicial review. During the discussion, however, he makes several other insightful remarks on the limited nature of the law’s generality as applied to future cases; he remarks on the primacy of the text of the law (as the words were publicly understood at the time of enactment) in relation to the problematic nature of ascertaining “legislative intent”); and he expresses deep reservations about the impropriety of the Court going anywhere near political questions.
In Lecture II. “The Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments,” Hand confesses that, in his view, judicial review regarding either “due process” is confined to the examination of the abuse of constitutional authority, period. If a legislature enacts a new law, one must assume that it did so in the face of an occasion causing discontent with the status quo and the belief that the law will be beneficial to society. That belief involves a choice involving an appraisal (balancing) of values and sacrifices anticipated as a result of the law. But values and sacrifices are “incommensurables” that, under our American Constitution, it is every American must evaluate or “weigh” on his or her own when making choices. For a Court to step in and “decide” such matters “impartially” is impossible, for those sorts of choices are those that are, as a matter of logic in relation to the incommensurable nature of value, for the people themselves to make; moreover, it by definition impedes upon the people’s sovereignty to think and choose freely, rendering it conceptually impossible as a matter of constitutional law. Any other conclusion renders the Court a third legislative chamber. It is, for Hand, a simple “question of power,” concluding that “I cannot frame any definition that will [accurately predict] when the Court will [improperly] assume the role of a third legislative chamber and when it will [properly] limit [itself] to keeping Congress and the states within their accredited authority.”
In Lecture III., “The Guardians,” Hand considers the First Amendment in relation to the arguments made thus far. He repeats his admonition that expanding the constitutional meanings of the other amendments “beyond their historical meaning” is a violation of the judicial function, which in his view lies in policing legislatures to make sure their value choices are honestly made and perceived sacrifices honestly appraised: “The statute may be far from the best solution of the conflicts with which it deals; but if it is the result of an honest effort to embody that compromise,” the “due process” inquiry ends. (He makes the same point regarding Equal Protection, “between which I [Hand] do not distinguish.”) Hand then criticizes the Court for its continuing usurpation of the people, which he worries will someday be viewed as commonplace. Then Hand reminds us that there are other checks, other safety mechanisms, in place to guard against “public hysteria, panic, greed,” and “sudden swings of popular obsession” made manifest in laws (coming out of the House of Representatives), as the Senate and a Presidential veto. Hand also remarks on the “permanent” nature of Court rulings, the Court’s capacity to do “serious damage” that “cannot be undone.” He then warns of the impending disaster that will become of the judicial appointment process should Americans continue to tolerate the Court’s continued encroachment, as well as the inevitable political “splits” that will become commonplace in all the appellate courts, which will in turn wreck the people’s confidence that what judges are doing is “really” law at all.
Hand concludes by assuring us that he is more than aware of the deeper “ever present problem in all popular government: how far the will of immediate majorities should prevail.” To this he replies that: “Each one of us must in the end choose for himself how far he would like to leave our collective fate to the wayward vagaries of popular assemblies. No one can fail to recognize the perils to which the last forty years have exposed such governments. We are not indeed forced to choose between absolutism and the kind of democracy that so often prevailed in Greek cities during the sixth to fourth centuries before our era. The Founding Fathers were acutely, perhaps overacutely, aware of the dangers that had followed that sort of rule, though, as you all know, they differed widely as to what curbs to impose. For myself it would be most irksome to be ruled by a bevy of Platonic Guardians, even if I know how to choose them, which I assuredly do not. If they were in charge, I should miss the stimulus of living in a society where I have, at least theoretically, some part in the direction of public affairs. Of course I know how illusory would be the belief that my vote determined anything; but nevertheless when I go to the polls I have a satisfaction in the sense that we are all engaged in a common venture.”
In 1952, for the Introduction of Hand’s The Spirit of Liberty, Irving Dillard wrote that “Learned Hand has sought to see as far as he could.”
How prescient he was.
The Bill of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), by Learned Hand PDF
The Bill of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), by Learned Hand EPub
The Bill of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), by Learned Hand Doc
The Bill of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), by Learned Hand iBooks
The Bill of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), by Learned Hand rtf
The Bill of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), by Learned Hand Mobipocket
The Bill of Rights (Oliver Wendell Holmes Lectures, 1958), by Learned Hand Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar